Chairman of the Board: Ahmed HammamEditor-in-Chief: Ayman Badra
College Football Playoff Rankings Reaction: Notre Dame Slighted, SEC Benefits from New Metric
Articles · 11:33:25 - Monday, November 16, 2026
Articles

College Football Playoff Rankings Reaction: Notre Dame Slighted, SEC Benefits from New Metric

The College Football Playoff selection committee released its first Top 25 rankings of the 2026 season on Tuesday, sparking immediate debate over the placement of several prominent programs. The initial rankings revealed a heavy influence from a newly introduced strength-of-conference metric, which appears to have lifted the SEC to an unprecedented level of representation.

All six two-loss SEC teams are ranked higher than they appear in both the AP and coaches polls. Two-loss Alabama and Texas sit at No. 5 and No. 7 respectively, ahead of undefeated UCLA at No. 8. If a 24-team playoff began today, nine of the 16 spots would go to SEC schools. Committee chairman Hunter Yurachek acknowledged the conference's lobbying efforts over the past two years, but the disparity between the metric's described role as an "enhancement" and its actual impact as the primary differentiator has drawn criticism.

Notre Dame debuted at No. 11, a full seven spots lower than its AP ranking — the largest gap in the initial CFP rankings. Yurachek cited the lack of a "signature win" as the primary reason, pointing to the Fighting Irish's loss to BYU. With only a matchup against No. 1 Miami remaining on the schedule, Notre Dame's margin for error is effectively zero, and history suggests the committee may continue to adjust the Irish's position even with a victory.

Alabama's No. 5 placement has also raised eyebrows. The Tide's resume includes a road win at Kentucky and a victory over a Mississippi State team that was without starting quarterback Kamario Taylor and went winless in October. Six teams ranked below Alabama boast better records against the CFP Top 25, yet the committee appeared impressed by the Kentucky win.

Ohio State finds itself at No. 12, the first team out of the playoff field, despite defeating reigning national champion Indiana on the road. Yurachek stated the committee never directly compared Indiana and Ohio State head-to-head, a revelation unlikely to sit well in Columbus. Meanwhile, undefeated UCLA sits at No. 8 while fellow unbeaten Utah holds No. 3, despite UCLA owning a stronger strength of schedule. New Mexico, ranked 22nd in the AP poll, is the only AP-ranked team absent from the CFP Top 25, even though its lone loss came by a touchdown on the road to SEC member Oklahoma.

Share this article: