Gotham FC has relocated its NWSL playoff semifinal against the Kansas City Current from Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, New Jersey, to Icahn Stadium on Manhattan's Randall's Island after players and coaches deemed the playing surface unsafe. The decision came roughly 24 hours after Gotham's 1-0 quarterfinal win over the Seattle Reign, during which coach Juan Carlos Amoros apologized for the pitch condition, calling it below the standard expected at this level.
Players from both teams described the field as "sandy," "unstable," and "atrocious," with visible rugby lines and leftover sand from a recent doubleheader. The NWSL had fined Gotham $10,000 for the field's state, even though the club does not manage the venue as a secondary tenant to MLS side RBNY. Despite a field consultant declaring the pitch met FIFA standards, the players' damning reviews and safety concerns prompted the move.
Discussions between Gotham, the NWSL, and RBNY to improve the surface — including re-sodding or a hybrid stitching solution — stalled because RBNY had a friendly against Club America scheduled for the following evening. RBNY declined the hybrid option over concerns it might not be completed in time for their match, leaving Gotham to seek an alternative venue.
RBNY acknowledged the frustration in a statement, noting the pitch was cleared for all matches this season and that they invest year-round in its maintenance. Gotham has previous experience at Icahn Stadium, having hosted two matches there, including a Concacaf W Champions Cup game in August 2025 where Amoros praised the pitch quality.
The episode underscores the NWSL's ongoing logistical challenges, with around half the league's teams operating as secondary tenants in stadiums they do not control. Scheduling conflicts with MLS landlords have forced venue changes for multiple clubs this season, including the Washington Spirit and Boston Legacy. Gotham will move to Etihad Park in 2028 but will remain a secondary tenant under New York City FC management, meaning similar issues could persist.



