NFL fans took to social media to react to a notable play by quarterback J.J. McCarthy during a game against the Washington Commanders at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey, on November 12, 2026. The play drew comparisons to Kansas City Chiefs star Patrick Mahomes, with one fan comment urging, "Don't let Cris Collinsworth see that," referencing the NBC broadcaster.
According to game photography from the event, McCarthy, listed as a New York Giants quarterback wearing number 18, was captured looking to throw during the contest. The image was credited to Ash Anjum of Pro Football Network.
Fan reactions highlighted the improvisational nature of the play, with many noting similarities to Mahomes' signature off-platform throwing ability. The social media buzz underscored the growing attention on McCarthy's development in the league.



