Chairman of the Board: Ahmed HammamEditor-in-Chief: Ayman Badra
Re-grading the Jaylen Brown-Paul George Trade: Celtics' Grade Improves, 76ers Remain Perfect
Articles · 01:38:24 - Thursday, November 19, 2026
Articles

Re-grading the Jaylen Brown-Paul George Trade: Celtics' Grade Improves, 76ers Remain Perfect

The blockbuster trade sending Jaylen Brown to the Philadelphia 76ers for Paul George and draft capital sparked immediate backlash in July, with many analysts giving Boston a failing grade. As the two teams prepare for their first meeting this season, both sit atop the Eastern Conference — Philadelphia at 9-2 and Boston at 8-2 with the conference's best net rating at +11.6 — prompting a reassessment of the deal.

Boston Celtics: B- (up from D-)

The initial criticism centered on two points: that a prime All-NBA forward should command four or five first-round picks, and that George, entering his age-36 season on a supermax contract after a career-worst year, represented neutral or negative value. However, the new collective bargaining agreement's apron rules have made teams wary of all-in moves for older stars, and recent comparable trades (Giannis Antetokounmpo, Mikal Bridges) suggest two first-round picks plus player value aligns with the current market.

George has defied expectations, averaging 20.4 points on 47-43-81 shooting with 4.1 assists and 2.33 steals per game. His 3-point attempt rate (51.4%) nearly doubles Brown's (27.8%), and his usage rate is nearly eight percentage points lower, fitting Joe Mazzulla's system alongside Jayson Tatum. George also leads the team in deflections and steals, helping Boston increase its free-throw rate and play faster — the Celtics now have the sixth-lowest average time per touch compared to eighth-highest last season.

Contractually, George's deal is a year shorter with no extension pressure, and his player option for 2025-26 could give Boston flexibility. Risks remain: George is 36, injury-prone, and his playoff performance will ultimately define the trade. The Celtics still struggle to generate rim pressure and lack a reliable perimeter defender for opposing star guards.

Philadelphia 76ers: A+ (unchanged)

Brown has seamlessly integrated, posting his lowest usage rate since 2020, turning the ball over half as often, and anchoring a defense ranked sixth in the NBA. He has publicly deferred to Tyrese Maxey, and the 76ers are winning close games with a starting lineup featuring four stars. The acquisition of Brown reportedly helped attract LeBron James on a minimum contract, whose surplus value offsets any concerns about Brown's salary.

Philadelphia also avoids immediate extension negotiations due to NBA rules, and Brown's reduced role may make a future non-max extension more palatable. The roster still holds four first-round picks over the next seven drafts, providing ammunition for future moves. Long-term challenges include managing a top-heavy payroll as Maxey, Brown, and rookie VJ Edgecombe command significant salaries, but the core of Maxey, Brown, and Edgecombe projects as a strong foundation for the next three to five years.

Both teams have thus far validated the trade: Boston maintained contention while adding draft assets and system fit, while Philadelphia opened an immediate championship window and secured a high baseline for the decade.

Share this article: