Some positions take longer to evaluate than others, but a year and a half is enough of a sample size to determine whether most of the top 2025 NFL Draft picks are on track to live up to expectations. While some, like Green Bay Packers wide receiver Matthew Golden, have already arrived as stars, others, including running backs Ashton Jeanty and Omarion Hampton, have regressed during the first 10 weeks of their sophomore season. Below are 10 players who underwhelmed as rookies and where they stand just over halfway through their second NFL seasons.
Cam Ward, QB, Titans – Verdict: Bounce-back
The season-long passing numbers and team record still leave a lot to be desired, but Cam Ward might be turning a corner. In his last two games, he posted a personal-best 304 passing yards against the Cincinnati Bengals and the third-best completion rate (71.8%) of his career against the Jacksonville Jaguars. Impressively, those performances came without standout rookie wide receiver Carnell Tate in the lineup. Ward is completing more passes, getting the ball out quicker, and taking fewer sacks. Head coach Robert Saleh said the team has decided to make "a shift philosophically" on how to let Ward handle the offense: "Philosophically, the change was, how are we going to evaluate if he's capable of being the franchise QB if we don't give him the opportunity to prove it. Over the last three weeks, he has done that." Through 25 career starts, Ward's completion rate (61%) matches Trevor Lawrence's at the same stage, with 21 passing touchdowns and a 79.8 passer rating.
Travis Hunter, CB/WR, Jaguars – Verdict: Bounce-back
A torn LCL in late October 2025 robbed the football world of Travis Hunter's rookie year just when it was starting to take off. Back at full strength in 2026, the two-way player recaptured his momentum and flourished into the star the Jaguars expected. Hunter's offensive snap count (47) shows he is a defense-first player, but he has a touchdown reception to his name. In Week 6, he became the first player since 2002 and just the fifth since the merger to record a touchdown reception and an interception in the same game. His PFF defensive grade ranks 11th league-wide at cornerback; he has allowed a passer rating of just 52.8 across 35 targets and has hauled in three interceptions, leading all Jaguars defensive backs and ranking 10th in the league among defensive backs with at least 20 targets.
Will Campbell, OT, Patriots – Verdict: Bounce-back
Will Campbell just completed his worst game of the season, allowing six pressures, an 18.2% pressure rate, and two sacks in the loss to the Detroit Lions, one of which injured Drake Maye's ankle. Even so, that performance ballooned what had been a quietly improved year. Before that game, Campbell's 5.9% pressure rate allowed led the team and was fourth among all tackles with at least 100 pass blocks. His pressure rate and sacks allowed have improved from 11.2% and 8.5 last year to 7.0% and 2.5 through 10 games, according to Next Gen Stats. His mistakes remain devastating but are fewer and further between.
Ashton Jeanty, RB, Raiders – Verdict: Letdown
Jeanty was initially projected as a can't-miss running back prospect after his Heisman Trophy finalist senior campaign at Boise State, but he hasn't translated his dominant ball-carrying ability to the NFL. His 41% rushing success rate as a rookie was as underwhelming as the 975 yards and five touchdowns he ran for, and even though the team has taken a step forward in 2026, Jeanty's production on the ground has regressed. Coach Klint Kubiak placed him in a timeshare and has gotten more out of him as a receiver than a runner. Jeanty ceded playing time to rookie Mike Washington Jr. and saw a soft benching in Week 8. Through Week 10: Jeanty – 123 carries, 380 yards, 1 TD; 46 receptions, 417 yards, 3 TD. Washington Jr. – 79 carries, 298 yards, 1 TD; 4 receptions, 15 yards. The Raiders average a league-low 1.5 yards before contact per rushing attempt, and lead the league in tackles for loss on called runs (34) and stuffed runs (58).
Mykel Williams, EDGE, 49ers – Verdict: Letdown
The San Francisco 49ers made Mykel Williams the third defensive lineman off the board, expecting him to quickly become the next stellar lineman. He started all nine games as a rookie but suffered a season-ending torn ACL. Now more than midway through his second season, Williams has only played in 14 career games and owns 2.5 sacks. He has yet to play more than half of all defensive snaps in the five games he has appeared in this season. His eight pressures give him a 9.6% pressure rate, but his average time to pressure of 3.69 seconds is tied for 15th-longest among 191 defensive linemen with at least 50 pass rush snaps. Only one of his eight pressures came within 2.5 seconds of the snap. The 49ers acquired DeForest Buckner at the trade deadline; since joining, the 32-year-old Buckner has nearly caught up to Williams in snap count (84 to 126) and has just as many quick pressures through two games (1) as Williams has all season.
Shemar Stewart, EDGE, Bengals – Verdict: Letdown
There was an opportunity for Cincinnati Bengals edge rusher Shemar Stewart to level up into a regular starter when Trey Hendrickson left in free agency. Instead, the former No. 17 pick has seen his role dramatically decrease in 2026. Stewart has just 52 defensive snaps all season and has been a healthy scratch multiple times (Weeks 1, 3, 6, 7). Outside of a Week 2 game where he registered a sack in five snaps, the rest of his reps have been minimal: zero pressures, zero sacks, and just one tackle assist over his last five games played. Offseason acquisition Boye Mafe slid into the job, and even second-round rookie Cashius Howell has made a bigger impact with a sack and 12 pressures.
Omarion Hampton, RB, Chargers – Verdict: Letdown
While Justin Herbert has been the face of the Los Angeles Chargers' offensive disappointment, Hampton is just as much of an underperformer. Offensive coordinator Mike McDaniel's history of featuring productive running backs has not translated to L.A., and Hampton is a second-year bust because of that reality. His per-game and per-touch production is dramatically worse year-over-year: 2025 – 4.4 yards/attempt, 60.6 yards/game, 51.4% receiving success rate, 21.3 receiving yards/game; 2026 – 3.6 yards/attempt, 46.1 yards/game, 38.5% receiving success rate, 7.9 receiving yards/game. The -46 rushing yards over expected he tallied in his first eight games ranked 123rd among 132 running backs. Los Angeles ranks ninth in ESPN's run block win rate metric, yet Hampton is hardly holding up his end.
Matthew Golden, WR, Packers – Verdict: Bounce-back
Golden totaled 361 receiving yards as a rookie. It took him only five weeks to outdo that total in his breakout sophomore season. The former No. 23 overall pick — the Packers' first first-round wide receiver in 23 years — is the fifth-leading receiver in the NFL with 853 yards. He is one of just three receivers who have already broken 100 targets through Week 10, alongside CeeDee Lamb and Jaxon Smith-Njigba, showing the sky-high confidence Jordan Love has in him. Golden has emerged as one half of a stellar duo with Christian Watson, both ranking in the top seven in receiving yards per game. Green Bay seems to have hit a home run with its rare swing at a first-round receiver and might own one of the NFL's best one-two punches at the position. Golden and Watson join Cincinnati's Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins as the only receiving pair with at least 800 yards and five touchdowns through the first 10 weeks.
Tyleik Williams, DT, Lions – Verdict: Bounce-back
The Detroit Lions defense takes more heat than praise, but the tide is turning, and Tyleik Williams is a big part of that. The Lions' defensive woes stem mostly from the secondary; up front, the group is actually quite stout against the run, ranking fifth in yards allowed per game and 10th in defensive rushing EPA per play. Williams is the anchor around which that run-stopping system operates. Last year he was a rotational element; now he is a fixture, helping a defense that ranked in the bottom 10 last year in rush EPA per play allowed climb into the top 10. He eats space and plugs gaps, and only Malcolm Rodriguez, Derrick Barnes, and Jack Campbell own more run stops among Lions defenders. Williams is also a sure tackler: he is one of just 10 defensive linemen in the entire NFL with at least 100 snaps against the run who has not missed a tackle this year, according to Next Gen Stats.
Maxwell Hairston, CB, Bills – Verdict: Bounce-back
A lack of interceptions and only two passes defended make Maxwell Hairston a modest factor of the Buffalo Bills secondary at face value. But a deeper dive into his coverage explains how he has outperformed his up-and-down rookie season. Per Next Gen Stats: Hairston owns the lowest completion percentage allowed of any Buffalo defensive back targeted at least 10 times. His -18.5% completion percentage over expectation is the second-best in the NFL among defensive backs with at least 20 targets. He ranks 15th among such defensive backs in EPA per target at -0.37. Davison Igbinosun took Hairston's starting job after four games, but that is more a testament to Igbinosun than a knock against Hairston. Ultimately, he looks poised to settle into a role covering smaller, speedier receivers while Igbinosun locks down taller, more physical wideouts.



