The New York Giants entered a new era under head coach John Harbaugh and made two first-round selections in the 2026 NFL Draft that have defined their early season. With the fifth overall pick they chose Ohio State linebacker Arvell Reese, a player many viewed as a luxury given the team's existing pass-rush depth. At No. 10 they selected former Miami right tackle Francis Mauigoa, intending to solidify the offensive line in front of young quarterback Jaxson Dart.
Reese's immediate impact
Through Week 9, Reese has validated the Giants' decision to take the best player available. According to TruMedia, he has converted 85 pass-rush snaps into 4.5 sacks, all coming over the last four games, including three sacks in Week 9 that strengthened his Defensive Rookie of the Year case. In the run game he plays square to the line of scrimmage and slips blocks to make tackles in the gap. As a coverage defender he shows the range and speed to trail running backs and tight ends. There is room for improvement — he can avoid getting sucked into the box and trust his eyes more — but the early returns are impressive.
Mauigoa's transition to guard
Mauigoa, a former right tackle at Miami, has moved to right guard with veteran Jermaine Eluemunor holding the right tackle spot. The transition has been inconsistent. His best performance came against the Texans' pass rush, where he displayed independent hand usage and angled blocks to seal run lanes for Cam Skattebo. However, he occasionally loses depth in the pocket, his eyes are not always in the right place to pick up stunts, and the bull rush has given him trouble, resulting in 4 sacks and 14 pressures allowed this season per TruMedia. Aspects of his game should improve with more repetitions at guard, though he appears to miss the edge he played with at Coral Gables.
Long-term outlook
The odds of Reese being anything less than a good player are slim; he already looks like one of the better linebackers in the NFL and his value could rise if the Giants deploy him more as a pass rusher. For Mauigoa, the evaluation hinges on his eventual position. If the Giants plan to move him back to tackle, the No. 10 pick was well-founded. If he remains at guard, they might have been better served selecting a player with more guard experience, such as Vega Ioane. The jury is still out on his ceiling, but he has quickly filled one of five starting offensive line spots, which carries inherent value.


