An analysis by Ansley Gavlak for USA TODAY Sports examines the flaws in high school football playoff systems where winning records do not always guarantee postseason berths. The piece highlights how selection criteria beyond win-loss records — such as strength of schedule, point differentials, and computer rankings — can leave deserving teams on the sidelines.
The article argues that the current playoff structures in many states create inequities, rewarding teams that play tougher schedules or penalizing those in weaker conferences. Critics say the emphasis on metrics other than victories undermines the fundamental principle that winning should be the primary path to the playoffs.
While the specifics vary by state, the overarching concern is that the playoff selection process lacks transparency and consistency, leading to frustration among coaches, players, and communities. The analysis calls for a reevaluation of playoff qualification standards to ensure that winning remains the most reliable ticket to the postseason.



